| 5*Oznome - Data rating | ||||
| Self-assessment | https://oznome.csiro.au/5star/?view=5ec2a9654d0983adde57a21e | |||
| Data Rating | https://confluence.csiro.au/display/OZNOME/Data+ratings | |||
| publication and indexing | FAIR Force11 | Data INRAE | ODAM - data | |
| Published | is the data accessible to users other than the creator or owner? | Bespoke web service (informal API) | Bespoke web service (OpenAPI/Swagger) | |
| Citeable | denoted using a formal identifier | A1 | Persistent web identifier (URI) | |
| Described | tagged with metadata | R1, F2, F3 | Basic metadata (e.g. Dublin Core) | |
| Findable | indexed in a discovery system | R1, F2, F3 | highly ranked in general purpose index (e.g "frim tomato" in Google) | |
| linked and useable | ||||
| Loadable | represented using a common or community-endorsed (i.e. standard) format | I1 | descriptive metadata: multiple standard formats (Dublin Core, DDI, Datacite, JSON-LD, JSON) | data & structural metadata : multiple standard formats (XML, JSON, TSV) |
| Useable | structured using a discoverable, community-endorsed (standard?) schema or data model | I2, R1.3 | descriptive metadata : explicit schema or data model, formalized in DDL, XSD, DDI, RDFS, JSON-Schema, data-package or similar | data & structural metadata : explicite schema formalized in data-package based on JSON-Schema |
| Comprehensible | supported with unambiguous definitions for all internal elements | I2 | descriptive metadata : some fields linked to externally managed definitions | structural metadata : all fields linked to standard, externally managed definitions |
| Linked | to other data and definitions using public identifiers (e.g. URIs) | I3 | out-bound links to related data and definitions | NA |
| Licensed | conditions for re-use are available and clearly expressed | R1.1 | link to a standard license (e.g. Creative Commons) | link to a standard license (e.g. Creative Commons) |
| maintenance and provenance | ||||
| Curated | commitment to ensuring the data is available long term | A2 | institutional repository (Data INRAE) | platform repository (Bordeaux Metabolome) |
| Updated | part of a regular data collection program or series, with clear maintenance arrangements and update schedule | one-time dataset | ||
| Assessable | accompanied by, or linked to, a data-quality assessment and description of the origin and workflow that produced the data | R1.2 | no quality or lineage information | |
| Trusted | accompanied by, or linked to, information about how the data has been used, by whom, and how many times | no information about usage | ||
| Project, organisational, institutional | ||||
| Complexity of the project | medium | |||
| Cross-organisational project? | 3 organisations | |||